(click the picture to pin it for later)
We have had a lot of nice feedback to our Homemade Liquid Coffee Creamer! I hope it is able to help you have your same old cup of Joe for less!
For those of you thinking, “I wish there was a recipe for powdered creamer” – we heard you! I have been playing around with some powdered coffee creamer ‘recipes’ so I could find just the right combination of simplicity and frugality! 😉
Homemade Powdered Coffee Creamer
(click the picture to pin it for later)
As I mentioned before, I am not a “plain creamer” kind of girl. I like a little flavor in my coffee, french Vanilla being my fave. However, before you start adding all kinds of fun flavors to your creamer, we need to first start with a “base” creamer. This is the combination that worked the best for me:
1 Cup Powdered Milk
1/2 Cup Powdered Sugar
1 tablespoon melted coconut oil
Mix together the dry ingredients. Slowly drizzle the melted coconut oil over the dry ingredients. (Since it has been pretty warm here, I did not have to melt my coconut oil – it was already quite ‘liquidy’.) I put the lid on my jar and shook like crazy. I then took a butter knife and broke up any bigger pieces, then shook again. The heavier coconut oil tends to settle, so I suggest making this in a container that can be tightly sealed so you can mix it a bit before you use it. (I used a mason jar – love them!)
Why Coconut Oil
If you like regular, no-flavored coffee creamer, I am confident you will like this base recipe. It adds a nice creamy texture to your coffee that the store bought creamers add. You may ask, “Why the coconut oil?” Well, this adds that extra bit of creaminess that is oh so yummy in store bought creamers. I tried making this creamer without the coconut oil, and it just wasn’t the same. It is kind of hard to explain, but try your creamer in your coffee before adding the coconut oil and you will see what I mean.
This will save you money!
Is it cheaper to make your own powdered coffee creamer? Yes! Here is the cost break down, in case you are like me and like to see the proof!
Powdered Creamer costs about $4 for a 35 oz container, which is about $0.11 per ounce. (I am basing this off the Walmart Best Choice creamer – Coffee Mate would be more expensive, even with a coupon.)
Here is what I spent:
Powdered Sugar, 2 lb bag – $1.50 = $0.19 per 1/2 cup
Powdered Milk, 8 qt box – $6.98 = $0.22 per 1 cup
Coconut Oil, 14 oz – $6.42 = $0.23 per tablespoon
Now its time to get excited! Altogether my 12 ounces of homemade creamer cost just $0.64. That comes to just $0.05 per ounce!! That means if you made 35 ounces of this homemade creamer, it would only cost you $1.86! That is a far cry from $4! Can I get a woo-woo?!
(click the picture to pin it for later)
Flavor Variations
If you are like me and you like a little flavor in your creamer, you can try adding these variations to the base creamer:
French Vanilla
one drop of vanilla extract to your coffee
OR 1 tablespoon of vanilla powder
Vanilla Caramel
(I know someone asked about this)
1-2 tablespoons brown sugar
1 tablespoon vanilla powder
*If you use brown sugar, this may cause your other ingredients to dry out. Try using a Brown Sugar Bear inside your sealed container to maintain the freshness.*
Hazelnut
1 tablespoon Hazelnut syrup (add very slowly – may even need to mix in blender to prevent clumps)
Irish Cream
1-2 tablespoons cocoa powder
1 teaspoon instant coffee granules
1-2 teaspoons vanilla powder
Will you join the “homemade revolution?” 😉 Make your own creamer – liquid or powdered – and use it for a full 2 weeks. I guess you will convert your ways!
Which Creamer Will You Make?
Don’t forget to check out more posts on our frugal living page to help you save money without clipping a coupon!
Jess says
Coconut oil also is a great immunity booster
Carla says
How do you store this and how long does it last?
Carrie says
You can store it on the shelf or in the fridge. It should last several months.
Lisa Thakkar says
Can I make this without the powdered sugar? My husband likes powdered creamer, but doesn’t use sugar…
Christine says
Just used this coffee creamer in my homemade hot cocoa mix – absolutely delicious!! Thank you for sharing!
Meaghan says
I’d too like to know whether you can make this without sugar. I usually use agave as a sweetener, and I’d like to avoid the sugar if I can. This looks great though!
Bob says
Of course you can make it without sugar. Usually powdered creamer is loaded with sugar. To make without sugar, just leave it out or add the equivalent non-sugar sweetener of your choice. BTW, agave nectar is a type of sugar. But to each his (or her) own.
Jim says
Woo-hoo!
🙂
Thanks!
Leigh Ann says
I can’t find vanilla powder. Do you think if I put all the ingredients in a blender and added a dash of vanilla extract that would work?
Kim says
I have a few questions about coconut oil, vanilla powder and the hazelnut syrup….How can I email you??
Sheila says
Thank you so much for a powdered creamer that uses real food in the ingredients!!! This creamer is so creamy and it tastes awesome. I made the base creamer exactly as it’s written, I didn’t change anything.
Carol Beck says
How do I make vanilla powder? Thanks for the recipes, can not wait to start making these.
D.Summers says
Can I just put a whole vanilla bean into the mixture instead of the vanilla powder or extract? Probably refrigerate for a couple weeks before using?
Pure GC Extract says
An impressive share! I’ve just forwarded this onto a co-worker who had been doing a
little research on this. And he actually ordered me breakfast because I discovered it for him…
lol. So allow me to reword this…. Thanks for
the meal!! But yeah, thanx for spending the time to discuss this subject here on your
website.
Aurora Bella moisturizer says
Just wanna state that this is very helpful, Thanks for
taking your time to write this.
Kytotrim And Kyto Cleanse says
This design is spectacular! You most certainly know how to keep a reader amused.
Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Excellent job.
I really enjoyed what you had to say, and more
than that, how you presented it. Too cool!
Laurene says
I made this yesterday and tried it in my coffee this morning and I love it! I wont be buying any other creamers at the store. I always felt that the other creamer I used had a metallic after taste which I didn’t like at all. Thanks for the recipe. I know if I want a flavored creamer now that I would know what to do. So easy thanks to you!
Sandra Fann says
A print friendly version would be appreciated
carrie says
Thanks for the suggestion Sandra!
Deb says
For those of us with a coconut allergy do you have an alternative?
carrie says
I would try leaving it out or you could try MCT oil. Thanks!
Patricia Huckstadt says
I was sooooooo excited to actually find a recipe for powdered coffee creamer, and I will definitely be making this! I have one question; since you use melted coconut oil, which would be a liquid, will the creamer be dry/powdered? I don’t get how it would be a powdered creamer when you add a liquid,melted coconut oil 😕.
carrie says
Since it’s a small amount it doesn’t fully affect the powders and they are still in a powder form. Thank you.
Kristen says
Thanks so much for this recipe! I usually buy coffee mate in the large Plastic containers but have always been concerned about
Adding more plastic into the environment thus I have been trying to use as little plastic as possible. I cant wait to make this coffee creamer this morning and I will be able to keep a good supply in a mason jar…..thanks so much for sharing
Kristen on HIltonHead Island
carrie says
Thank you Kristen!
Keith C says
Do you have a recipe for the Italian sweet cream coffee mate? It’s a favorite of mine.
carrie says
No I don’t right now.
Diane says
Will this work without the powdered sugar? I don’t use sugar. Wondering if it needs it for the consistency.